Spindle sander vs belt/disc sander: what each is for, per the makers
WEN describes oscillating spindle sanders as popular with woodworkers who need a sanded finish on outside or inside curves. RIKON lists spindle diameters from 1/2" to 3" on its 50-320, and WEN's 6515T pairs a 1-by-30 inch belt with a 5-inch disc.
What is an oscillating spindle sander for?
WEN says oscillating spindle sanders are popular with woodworkers who need a sanded finish on outside or inside curves, and are generally benchtop machines. (WEN Products)
WEN explains that they use a series of differently sized drums, suit projects with inside (concave) curves, and move the drums up and down while spinning, hence the name oscillating. (WEN Products)
Taikra doesn't rank or test tools; every figure here is from the maker's own page or manual, linked.
Spindle sizes and oscillation
RIKON lists spindle diameters of 1/2", 3/4", 1", 1-1/2", 2" and 3", a 4-1/2" spindle length and 2,000 RPM for the 50-320, with a 5/8" oscillation 58 times per minute. (RIKON Power Tools)
WEN lists 58 OPM, 2000 RPM and a 5/8 inch stroke for the 6510T, which ships with sanding sleeves from 1/2 in. to 3 in. (WEN Products)
What are belt and disc sanders for?
WEN describes belt sanders as using a long, wide belt to quickly remove lots of material or flatten relatively large areas, and notes that benchtop and floor-standing models are often combined with disc sanders. (WEN Products)
WEN says disc sanders are generally benchtop machines that are good for smoothing end grain in wood or light metal shaping. (WEN Products)
Belt and disc sizes
RIKON's 50-122 pairs a 6" x 48" belt at 1,836 SFPM with a 10" disc at 2,510 RPM, on a 1 HP motor, and its belt tilts 0 to 90 degrees. (RIKON Power Tools)
WEN's smaller 6515T pairs a 1-by-30 inch belt with a 5-inch disc, at up to 3160 FPM for the belt and 3450 RPM for the disc from a 2.3A motor. (WEN Products)
Spindle sander vs belt/disc sander: questions answered from the sources
Spindle sander or belt sander for curves?
WEN describes oscillating spindle sanders as the choice for inside and outside curves, especially concave ones, and belt sanders for fast stock removal and flattening.
Why does a spindle sander oscillate?
WEN explains that the drums move up and down while spinning; RIKON and WEN list a 5/8" stroke at 58 per minute.
Sources: The Different Types of Sanders and Their Uses; Model 50-320 Benchtop Oscillating Spindle Sander - Rikon Power Tools; WEN 6510T 3.5 Amp Oscillating Spindle Sander
What is a disc sander good for?
WEN says disc sanders are good for smoothing end grain in wood or light metal shaping, and are often combined with belt sanders.
Sources
- The Different Types of Sanders and Their Uses — WEN Products
- Model 50-320 Benchtop Oscillating Spindle Sander - Rikon Power Tools — RIKON Power Tools
- WEN 6510T 3.5 Amp Oscillating Spindle Sander — WEN Products
- Model 50-122: 6" x 48" Belt/ 10" Disc Sander - Rikon Power Tools — RIKON Power Tools
- WEN 6515T 1 x 30-Inch Belt Sander with 5-Inch Sanding Disc — WEN Products